Type of Case: Voter ID
Court: Dane County Circuit Court; District IV Court of Appeals; Wisconsin Supreme Court
Case Number: 2011-CV-4669; 2012-AP-584
Filed On: October 20, 2011
Current Status: Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled Voter ID constitutional
In 2008, the United States Supreme Court called “the risk of voter fraud real” and capable of changing “the outcome of a close election,” citing to Wisconsin as one of many states with recent examples of voter impersonation fraud. In order to combat those risks, Governor Walker signed 2011 Wisconsin Act 23, which imposed photo identification requirements on nearly all voters.
Liberal groups quickly filed suit, challenging Act 23 in four separate court cases – two federal and two state.
The judge in LWV concluded that the presentation of identification was an additional requirement to be a qualified voter beyond those requirements permitted by the Wisconsin Constitution. We believe that presenting identification is merely a method of establishing that you are, in fact, a qualified voter. The Court of Appeals agreed with us in this case, reversing the lower court and upholding voter ID.
On July 31, 2014, the Wisconsin Supreme Court affirmed the court of appeals, upholding the constitutionality of Voter ID. However, the court ordered that DOT officials permit anybody who cannot obtain a birth certificate without cost to be provided a voter ID without that supporting documentation, to avoid the imposition of a poll tax (a fee for voting).
- PDF: Court Order Granting Permanent Injunction
- PDF: Court of Appeals Certification
- PDF: Appellant’s Brief
- PDF: Amici Brief
- PDF: State’s Motion to Bypass and Consolidate
- PDF: Plantiff’s Response to the Motion to Consolidate
- PDF: Amici Brief in Support of Motion to Bypass and Consolidate
- PDF: Order Denying Motion to Bypass
- PDF: WILL Clients’ Amicus Brief
- PDF: State’s Reply Brief
- PDF: Intervenor’s Reply Brief
- PDF: Wisconsin Democracy Campaign Amicus Brief
- PDF: Dane County Amicus Brief
- PDF: Supreme Court Opinion