2025-26 Report Cards: High Marks for Very Low Reading Scores 

Post Date: November 17, 2026
Policy Type and Category:
icon document text Education Education Highlight
By:
policy will flanders
Will Flanders, PHD Research Director
Share on:
icon x icon facebook icon linkedin icon email

At Maple Tree Elementary in Milwaukee, just 7% of 3rd graders scored proficient on the Forward Exam in reading, yet the school was rated “Exceeds Expectations.” Across Milwaukee Public Schools (MPS), fewer than 1 in 4 students are proficient in reading, yet the district was rated as “Meets Expectations.” Statewide, only about half of Wisconsin students can read at grade level, even after the Department of Public Instruction (DPI) lowered the bar for proficiency in 2024. Yet on this year’s report cards, not one school district failed, and 95% met or beat expectations.

Those are among some of the key findings from the Department of Public Instruction’s 2025-26 Report Cards, which were released today. Opponents of school choice and charter schools talk a lot about accountability. But it’s hard to take that seriously when the state’s own report card hands out passing grades to schools where a majority of kids can’t read.

The Overall Picture

Figure 1 below shows the number of districts that fall into each of the five categories of proficiency on the report card. Zero districts fall into the lowest category, and only 19 out of 420 with scores (4.5%) fall into the “Meets Few Expectations” category. The vast majority of districts fall into “Meets Expectations” or “Exceeds Expectations.” In total, 95.5% of Wisconsin school districts are considered as “meeting expectations” or higher.

Figure 1. District Report Card Ratings, 2025-26

Bar chart of Wisconsin district report card ratings for 2025-26: zero districts Fail to Meet Expectations and 19 of 420 Meet Few Expectations

On last year’s report cards, zero districts also fell in the lowest category, but 25—6 more than this year—were in the “Meets Few Expectations” category. Perhaps this would be acceptable if Wisconsin was doing an exceptional job educating its students, but this is not the case. On the last national report card exam (NAEP), just 31% of Wisconsin fourth graders were proficient in reading, the lowest score the state has received since the test was created. Table 1 shows the districts in the state with the lowest proficiency in English/Language Arts (ELA) that were rated as “Meets Expectations” or higher on the report card.

Keep in mind that these proficiency ratings are on the lowered standard that DPI implemented behind closed doors in 2024, which makes them look better than they actually are. In fact, Wisconsin’s Forward Exam results in reading are 20 points higher than the NAEP. Even by this lowered standard, nine districts are rated as “Meets Expectations” with proficiency rates below 35% in ELA. One district, Goodman-Armstrong Creek, actually was rated as “Exceeds Expectations” with proficiency this low.

Table 1. Lowest-Proficiency Districts Meeting Expectations

District Rating ELA Proficiency
Lac du Flambeau Meets Expectations 23.20%
Milwaukee Meets Expectations 24.90%
Abbotsford Meets Expectations 26.30%
Bayfield Meets Expectations 28.60%
Crandon Meets Expectations 33.00%
La Farge Meets Expectations 33.30%
Siren Meets Expectations 34.00%
Goodman-Armstrong Creek Exceeds Expectations 34.10%
Bowler Meets Expectations 34.30%
Green Bay Area Public Meets Expectations 34.40%

The same story applies to the school-level report card. Statewide, 148 schools had fewer than 20% of students proficient in reading (ELA) in 2026. Of those, 41 of them (28%) were still rated “Meets Expectations” or higher. Seven schools where fewer than 1 in 10 students were proficient still earned three stars. They include 23 traditional public schools, 9 choice schools, 7 independent charters and 2 MPS charters. Table 2 shows the ten public schools in the state with the lowest proficiency rates that met or exceeded expectations by the metrics. Three schools even meet expectations with proficiency under 10%.

Table 2. Lowest-Proficiency Schools that Meet Expectations

District School Name Accountability Rating Percent Meeting ELA
Menominee Indian Menominee Nation High School Meets Expectations 8.70%
Milwaukee Siefert Elementary Meets Expectations 9.20%
Milwaukee Clemens Elementary Meets Expectations 9.60%
Milwaukee Carson Academy Meets Expectations 10.20%
Milwaukee King Jr Elementary Meets Expectations 10.70%
Milwaukee Grantosa Drive Elementary Meets Expectations 11.30%
Milwaukee Congress Elementary Meets Expectations 12.00%
Milwaukee Burbank Elementary Meets Expectations 12.10%
Milwaukee Doerfler Elementary Meets Expectations 13.30%
Milwaukee Story Elementary Meets Expectations 13.30%

How does this happen? It comes down to how DPI builds the score. The weight given to proficiency depends on how many low-income students the school serves. Once about 65% of a school’s students are low-income, proficiency only counts for about 5% of their overall score. Growth, or how much a student improves from one year to the next, counts for about 45%. Growth matters, but a school can post a strong report card score and still have nearly all of their students behind in a subject. WILL has advocated for changing this weighting to have less variability between schools, so parents have a more accurate measure of how a student population is performing.

Achievement Gaps

Wisconsin regularly records some of the largest achievement gaps in the nation, and this year’s report cards do little to dispel that reputation. Indeed, racial and economic achievement gaps remain enormous on this year’s exam. Figure 2 below shows the relationship between the percentage of African American and low-income students in a school and its ELA proficiency in a regression model that included other variables such as disability rate, school enrollment, and school sector.

Figure 2. Relationship of Income and Race to ELA Proficiency

Predicted difference in ELA proficiency

Low-Income
Black
−33.91%
−28.27%

The way to interpret these results is that, for a hypothetical school where all the students were low-income, proficiency in ELA would be predicted to be 33.91% lower than a school where no students were low-income. The same applies for the percentage of black students. With the largest number of black students in the state, Milwaukee is a key driver of this gap. In Milwaukee, only 15.5% of black students are proficient in ELA. Given the district spends $22,390 per student, it appears more funding is not the answer here.

Sector Performance

We can use similar regression techniques to look at the performance of private schools in the choice program relative to their public school counterparts with one caveat: disability rates are too mismeasured in choice schools to serve as a valid control variable. When we complete our annual Apples to Apples report, we will model disability rates. For this analysis, they are excluded and that should serve as a caveat on the findings.

The regression model reveals an advantage for private choice schools. Controlling for other factors, proficiency was about 6.47% higher in ELA and 3.02% higher in math than traditional public schools.

Figure 3. Choice Proficiency Relative to Public Schools

Predicted proficiency advantage for choice schools

+6.47%
+3.02%
ELA
Math

Conclusion

Wisconsin’s 2025-26 report cards continue a pattern of giving high marks to districts and schools where large shares of students—often well under 35 percent, and in dozens of cases under 20 percent—are not proficient in reading, even after DPI’s lowered cut scores. The persistence of some of the nation’s largest racial and economic achievement gaps, including Milwaukee’s 15.5 percent ELA proficiency rate for black students despite high per-pupil spending, shows that the system is still not confronting the scale of the problem. The bottom line is that the current report-card framework is too willing to declare success where student outcomes remain weak. WILL has proposed improvements to the state’s accountability system for years. Unfortunately, Governor Evers chose to reject a bill that would have implemented many of these reforms last year. Until the ratings more closely track actual proficiency, “accountability” will remain more slogan than substance.


Policy Author

Will Flanders, PHD

2025-26 Report Cards: High Marks for Very Low Reading Scores 

icon document text Education Education Highlight
Share on:
icon x icon facebook icon linkedin icon email